During Netflix’s Tudum event, Gaga performed a medley of her dark pop music, complete with an army of Wednesdays to do the dance, while inviting Ortega on stage for a meal of a moment. It really ratcheted up the excitement, but little was known about who Gaga would be portraying.

Nowadays, when you watch Wednesday and hear buzz about Lady Gaga’s upcoming cameo, you might imagine the excitement ricocheting across the set. Yet, for Hunter Doohan, who plays Tyler/Hyde, that thrill came with a side of playful disappointment.